헌번재판소 신행정수도이전특별법 위헌 판결

헌법재판소 전원재판부는 21일 신행정수도 건설특별법에 대한 헌법소원 사건에서 재판관 8대 1의 의견으로 위헌 결정을 내렸다.
헌재는 수도이전 문제가 헌법 개정 사항이거나 국민투표를 통해 결정할 사항이나 이런 절차를 거치지 않았다며 이 같이 결정했다.
이날 재판관중 노무현 대통령이 지명한 전효숙 재판관만이 헌법소원이 적법한 요건을 구비하지 못했다는 의견을 냈다.
이에따라 지난 7월 12일 접수된 이 사건은 심리 100여일만에 정부의 행정수도 이전을 둘러싼 위헌 논란에 종지부를 찍었지만 이번 위헌 결정으로 행정수도 추진은 전면 중단되게 됐다.
정부가 수도 이전을 재추진하려면 헌법을 개정해야 하고 이를 위해 국회에서 재적 의원 3분의 2의 찬성을 얻는 의결과 이후 국민투표를 거쳐야 한다.

▲ 21일 ‘신행정수도 건설 특별법’에 대해 위헌이라고 선고했다. /최순호 기자

재판부는 결정문에서 7명의 다수 의견을 통해 “서울이 수도라는 점은 헌법상 명문의 조항이 있는 것은 아니지만 조선 왕조 이래 600여년간 관습에 의해 형성된 관행이므로 관습 헌법으로 성립된 불문헌법에 해당된다”고 밝혔다.
재판부는 “‘수도는 서울’이라는 관습헌법을 폐지하기 위해서는 헌법이 정한 절차에 따른 헌법개정이 이뤄져야 한다”며 “정부는 헌법 개정절차를 거치지 않았으므로 헌법상 국민투표권을 침해한 위헌”이라고 말했다.
개헌을 하려면 국회의원 재적 과반수나 대통령 발의로 제안이 있은뒤 국회 재적의원 3분의 2 이상 찬성을 통해 국회를 통과한 뒤 30일 이내 국민투표에 부쳐 과반수 투표에 과반수 찬성을 얻어야 한다.
김영일 재판관은 위헌 의견을 개진하면서도 “수도이전은 헌법 72조가 정한 국방.통일 기타 국가 안위에 관한 중요정책에 해당된다”며 “이 경우 국민투표를 실시해야 함에도 이를 어긴 것은 72조의 국민투표권을 침해한 것”이라고 밝혔다.
반면 전효숙 재판관은 “서울을 수도로 한 관습헌법의 변경이 반드시 헌법개정을 요하는 문제라고 할 수 없다”며 “행정수도 이전정책 역시 국민투표를 요하는 사안이라고 볼 수 없어 헌법소원은 이유없다”는 각하의견을 냈다.
청구인측 이석연 변호사는 선고직후 “개혁이란 이름으로 헌법 정신을 무시한 채 국가를 분열시키고 갈등으로 몰고가는 집권세력에게 헌법의 가치가 살아있음을 보여준 결정”이라고 평가하면서 “수도이전을 추진하려면 개헌을 해야 한다는 뜻으로 정부는 원점에서부터 이 문제를 다시 검토해야 할 것”이라고 말했다.
정부측 오금석 변호사는 “헌재 결정을 존중해야 하겠지만 법 이론적으로는 소수의견이 타당하다고 본다”며 “다수의견은 정책판단에 따른 것으로 보이며 상당히 유감스럽게 생각한다”고 말했다.

6 thoughts on “헌번재판소 신행정수도이전특별법 위헌 판결”

  1. colleague to the definite Mabosway sports betting interchange by registering – Are
    you looking for an looking for excitement and new experience
    in the world of online gambling? You have arrive to the right place, because here
    you can link us, the best and most trusted gambling site agent in Indonesia!

    We are privileged to be dexterous to come up with the money for the best servants
    to members who are always loyal to trust us and create us a gambling
    partner. Therefore, we have prepared various types of fun and well-liked games such as
    Mabosway sports betting, casino, lottery, and others.

    Not and no-one else that, there are moreover many promos that we will provide and of course it is all aimed at the improvement of the members.
    every the facilities that are within acceptable limits for you in the same way as you become a zealot here.
    Here are some of our advantages over additional sites:

    The deposit and invalidation process is quick and accurate
    Members’ personal data and identities are always safe and
    will not leak to extra parties
    Mabosway login, one user ID that can be used
    for various types of games
    Customer staff who are always ready to support
    you 24/7
    Unlimited Bonuses and Promos
    The best sustain supported by years of experience has made
    Mabosway always trusted by its members and earned the title as
    the best gambling site agent in Indonesia.

  2. Ubobet is an internationally trusted gambling dealer past 2001 until now.

    By holding endorsed permission for online gambling sites that allow
    various types of betting games. Games manageable enhance Sportsbook,
    stir Casino and Cockfight. Ubobet has reached the entire world gambling
    shout out including the Indonesian market. At present, every
    hours of daylight there are more than 100 thousand players who entrust their bets in the
    city of Ubobet.

    Ubobet List Site

    To register an account, players cannot attain it directly on the Ubobet site.
    In additional words, prospective players must register through the attributed agent site for Ubobet listings such as Pandora188.

    By using Pandora188 ID the player can bet upon this city.

    How to register is quite easy, just by filling out the registration form correctly.
    After that make a accumulation of at least 25 thousand, subsequently the player can bet on Ubobet.
    all artist who joins as a advocate at Pandora188 is
    entitled to a freebet further and after that a daily growth added without exception.

    Ubobet Login

    After registering, players can log in upon Ubobet in two ways.

    The first is through attributed associates who have collaborations such
    as Pandora188. Because the two sites have already formed a partnership, which means that betting upon the Pandora188 site is the similar as betting on Ubobet directly.
    Or by the second artifice you can directly log in to the Ubobet site if you already have an account.
    How to log in Ubobet is quite easy, just enter your ID & password correctly.

  3. There are a lot of bookies in Indonesia who have been provoked to near their businesses in the past Indonesia adopted
    a play that prohibits every forms of gambling.
    Because of this phenomenon and is supported by technological advances that are unconditionally rapid, past then all gambling happenings are no longer carried
    out freely and without help shaped online such as online soccer betting or online casino.

    Progress is not without challenges, because the easier admission to recommendation technology,
    many irresponsible people begin to put up with advantage.
    Looking for allowance by scouting gambling agents and utilizing
    the fans of gambling off guard by scamming, fraud, phishing, etc.

    Different from Us! Our attributed site solitary gives members
    access to soccer gambling and online casino games that have been proven secure and reliable.
    Gambling games from gambling game provider sites
    that we offer, have a unquestionably fine reputation, both in terms of the system and its services to customers.

  4. Along later than the times, event developments have moreover developed throughout the world.
    The number of supplementary businesses that we don’t even know
    of exist because there are too many of them.
    Similarly, the gambling business, of course there are then many names of
    gambling agents that have sprung up. However, the emergence of these agents
    does not always meet the expense of a fine other for gamblers, both upscale and beginner gamblers.
    subsequently correspondingly many gambling agents popping up,
    categorically not all agents can be trusted because too many
    gambling business worlds desire to receive more
    profits without thinking more or less the long-term
    impact. Both members and for their own business.

    Ensuring Bandar Legality

    Therefore ascribed agent2018 wants to find the money for
    an simple showing off to locate a trusted gambling agent site.

    The aspire is that you can have an idea, how to handle
    the situation. next you are in a come clean already trapped
    by fraud traps. Because we all know in that position it’s impossible to get out soon. You are with complacent, appropriately you are not up to date that you are
    yet below the have an effect on of fraud from irresponsible agents.

    To find out the attributed gambling agent is completely
    easy, make definite taking into consideration you visit the gambling site, whether it’s a gambling site or similar, it’s a good idea to question the customer minister to whether the site is ascribed or
    not by asking for proof of ID number or belong to that can prove the existence of the site qualified soccer gambling
    is genuine and practicable to operate, usually an qualified
    online gambling site. Always has an office in the Philippines and is under the aegis of Cagayan or Pagcor,
    and has true immunity and authority. Which is protected by the permit of the Philippines,
    because the solitary country in Asia that is able to manage to pay for licenses for online
    gambling concern sites, is abandoned in the Philippines.
    easy acceptable right? To find a trusted online soccer betting
    site.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.